Writing is often a solitary activity. We dream up these worlds in our heads. Populate them with characters. Then bounce them off each other in a way that’s interesting… you hope.
Writing a first draft is hard.
Revising… that’s harder. Because eventually you’ll have to rip apart this script you’ve slaved so hard over, and you’ll be doing at least some of it through the lens of other people.
If that sounds scary, that’s because it is. But if you ever want to see your movie up on the screen, you’re going to show it to someone eventually. Better to rip that band-aid off quickly.
Okay… But Who?
Start with people around you. Friends, family, co-workers, etc. What you want is a good mix of experience. Some writers, some people in the industry, and then, like… your mom.
Seriously.
Most people don’t know how to write screenplays. But almost everyone watches movies and TV. It’s important to see how your stories impact as wide a group as possible.
That will only take you so far, though. Eventually, you’ll want in-depth notes from professionals. Is this character marketable? Does the 2nd act break make sense where it is, or does it need to be moved up?
It’s these nitty-gritty kind of notes that often take a long time to work through. As you make changes, you’ll create other issues. Then revising becomes like a game of whack-a-mole. So you’ll need a sustainable process.
Here’s how I approach it these days.
AI Reviewers
I know. But hear me out.
The film industry is deeply suspicious of AI, and for understandable reasons. Everyone’s terrified that AI will eventually take the jobs of creatives. Writers, CG artists… even actors.
But AI is a great tool for some things. Very helpful for research, for example. Proofreading. Sanity-checking changes you’ve made, especially when you get 20-30 versions deep into your script.
Also: Near-instant script notes.
There are a few ways to skin this particular cat.
For starters, I employ ChatGPT in the role of a writer’s assistant. Check these lines for me, help me smooth this out, what lines can I lose out of this section… that kind of thing. A lot of times, if nothing else, just having the AI to bounce ideas off of helps get the mind going on those days when the blank page and blinking cursor are intimidating.
Then, as I complete versions of my scripts, I run them by a few services.
One important thing before we go any further: don’t fall in love with the scores. An 82 isn’t objectively better than a 79. These are tools for finding problems, not judges handing down a verdict on whether your script is good.
Greenlight Coverage. One of the longest-existing AI script readers (which isn’t saying much; this industry is about five minutes old). It works on a subscription. For a monthly fee, you get 3-10 script reviews that run 20-25 pages. Its strengths are in detailed notes – why is this character doing this here, that kind of thing. Like a lot of AI readers, it tends to lose the thread of chronology and mix up act breaks. So it’s important to read its summaries to properly contextualize its notes. The TV notes get interesting. Sometimes they’re great. But when you submit a pilot, it basically makes up its own first season, and often starts bouncing your ideas off of its own, and gets itself confused.
Script Forge. One of the newer — and least expensive — services right now. Also good with the granular notes. It often picks up on subtleties better than other services – I find its character notes in particular to be insightful. It struggles with TV scripts right now, often outthinking itself on whether scripts are pilots or features, particularly on more complex stories. Because it’s so new, I’d expect it to advance quickly once it’s gotten more training.
First Pass. Another newer service that runs on a subscription. This one thinks more like a producer than a writer, giving its scores based on how prepared it thinks your script is to be pitched. While helpful, and it’s one I use regularly, the industry has been in a state of flux for years, and what it wants today, it may not want tomorrow. That means there will be a lag between your score and what’s actually happening in the industry. It’s important to take that into consideration, not only with this service but with all services that focus on script marketability.
Callaia. This gives the widest view of all the services, and is the only AI service I’ve used that’s pay-per-script… one script, one fee (though you can get discounts if you buy more in advance). It often has the best balance of plot vs character, and understands a lot of subtlety, plus it seems to read scripts quite well from a chronological perspective. Its notes don’t shift much with a lot of small changes, though, so don’t expect your score to move with a lot of small changes.
Human Reviewers
Like a lot of the entertainment industry, human script review companies are very much in flux right now.
For a long time, we screenwriters had Coverfly, which was a brilliant service. It served as a clearinghouse for script competitions. Then it actually kept your score and ranked your scripts for producers to search and see. Its demise was a big blow to the screenwriting community.
My favorite service for script coverage has long been Stage 32. It has various levels of human coverage, ranging from a couple of basic pages, all the way through five pages and an hour-long meeting with a development executive. I actually found my manager through one of these. They usually turn scripts around in just a couple of days (most services promise 2-3 weeks).
The Blacklist is another popular one. I haven’t used this one in a long time after a string of particularly unhelpful notes, but a lot of people swear by it. It also ranks scripts similarly to Coverfly. There is a distinction between using this service and getting on the actual industry Blacklist. Don’t confuse high scores on the service with making the annual list. They’re two different things.
Finally, the best human reviewers are often solo guys like myself (yes, I can review your script for you – click here to learn more). What’s good about folks like me is you can actually build a relationship with a reviewer as you delve deeper into a script, unlike the anonymous reviews you get from a lot of services.
So… Who Do You Listen To?
Everyone.
And no one.
The point of getting notes isn’t to get someone else’s approval or a good grade. This isn’t junior high. It’s to get a bunch of different perspectives that will allow you to see your script from a lot of different angles.
People. Industry executives, all the way down to your mom.
AI. Cause you know what? Producers and reps are using it for their own coverage. So if nothing else, you need to see what they’re seeing.
Then comes the really hard part: What to do next.
But that’s another post. Come back for more. 😉


